Gloucester County Republicans will mount a legal challenge to a Democratic plan to use an office block ballot design in the November general election.
The county clerk, Democrat James Hogan, redesigned the ballots without advising the Republicans. He did so after a ballot draw that gave Column A to Republicans and Column B to Democrats.
In court papers filed on Friday, the GOP lawyers argued that the redesign is unlawful – Hogan, they said, “failed to design the general election ballot in a grid format with columns of candidates for each political party and rows for each office in the order specified by statute,” – and said they’ve already expended resources to tell voters where to find Republican candidates on the ballot.
“It is not possible to contact every voter who has read these communications to inform them that the Gloucester ballot is non-conforming with state law,” said the attorneys, Marla DeMarcantonio and Josiah Contarino. “The result is significant voter confusion.”
Hogan’s move could help Democrats in legislative and countywide elections, where coattails are potentially significant.
Jack Ciattarelli carried Gloucester County in 2021 by ten points over Gov. Phil Murphy — a margin that helped Republicans elect a sheriff, flip two county commissioner seats, and seize all three legislative seats in the competitive 3rd District. Democrats clawed back in 2023, winning Senate and Assembly seats. In 2024, voters returned the two GOP commissioners, even as Donald Trump carried the county by just three points.
This year, control of county government is on the line: two commissioner seats are up, and if Republicans sweep both, they’ll take charge of Gloucester County for the first time since 1980.
Superior Court Judge Benjamin Telsey will hold a case management conference on Monday afternoon. Telsey will have a short window to move the case forward before sample ballots go out and early voting begins in October.
