Voters in East Newark will decide on November 3 whether to reduce their school board from nine members to seven, but Hudson County election officials have already removed two vacant seats from the ballot, effectively treating the referendum as though voters had approved it.
The decision means voters in the tiny Hudson County borough of 2,594 residents, located across the Passaic River from Newark, will not have an opportunity to elect two school board members to fill unexpired terms, even though those seats remain legally authorized.
The controversy began with the 2025 school board election, when no candidates filed for three available seats. Three individuals won through write-in votes, but two failed to satisfy the legal requirements to take office.
The seats remained vacant for much of 2026 after no one applied to fill them. Eventually, Hudson County Superintendent of Schools appointed Fernando Fernandez and Jessica Diaz to serve until an election could be held.
By August, three candidates had filed for three full three-year terms on the November ballot, but no one filed for the two unexpired two-year terms.
Under state law, the absence of candidates does not eliminate an election. Guidance from the New Jersey School Boards Association makes clear that even a single write-in vote can elect a qualified candidate willing to serve.
But Hudson County election officials omitted both contests from the November ballot.
According to county officials, East Newark Board of Education attorney Karen Murray determined the elections could be canceled because voters might approve a referendum reducing the board’s membership from nine to seven and eliminating the two vacancies.
No record shows that the East Newark Board of Education voted to eliminate the two seats or authorized their removal from the ballot.
Murray did not answer a call to her cell phone or respond to a text message seeking comment.
The decision raises questions about whether county election officials can remove contests for existing school board seats before a referendum passes.
Under state law, reducing a school board from nine members to seven is a phased process that preserves the terms of sitting members. The law does not provide for the immediate elimination of two vacant seats simply because voters approve a reduction.
Separately, the statute provides for elections to fill the remaining terms of appointed school board members.
If voters reject the referendum, East Newark will retain a nine-member board without having given voters the opportunity to elect anyone to the two unexpired terms.

