Gov. Mikie Sherrill will appoint Shirley U. Emehelu, a former federal and state prosecutor and longtime friend and émigré from Nigeria who has not been actively involved in partisan politics, as New Jersey’s fifth lieutenant governor, and is expected to announce the appointment on Monday, the New Jersey Globe has confirmed.
Emehelu will succeed Rev. Dale Caldwell, who resigned in September after an internal investigation substantiated allegations that he sexually harassed a female staffer and violated state ethics rules.
The 48-year-old Montclair resident joined the Sherrill administration in January, first as acting state comptroller and then as acting secretary of State in September, replacing Caldwell and taking over the administration of the November 3 general election.
The appointment, which does not require Senate confirmation, puts Emehelu next in the line of succession behind a governor considered to have national political ambitions. She will serve as acting governor when Sherrill leaves the state.
Sherrill had narrowed her choices to two finalists: Emehelu and Assemblywoman Verlina Reynolds-Jackson (D-Mercer), the chair of the Assembly Education Committee. Her final short list also included former Associate White House Counsel Justin Dews and Bergen County Sheriff Anthony Cureton. Another serious candidate, Assemblyman Chigozie Onyema (D-Newark), withdrew his name from consideration a few weeks ago. At one point, Sherrill’s list included two outsiders, former Apprentice winner and Donald Trump critic Randal Pinkett and Squire Servance, an attorney and businessman who ran for Congress earlier this year.
The governor’s office declined to comment or confirm Sherrill’s pick of Emehelu.
This will be the first time New Jersey will have women serving as both governor and lieutenant governor and will become the fifth state to do so. New York and New Mexico will join the list in January.
Emehelu first joined state government in 2022 as executive assistant attorney general, the third-highest-ranking official in the New Jersey Attorney General’s Office, during Gov. Phil Murphy’s second term. She was named to the post by Attorney General Matt Platkin.
Late last year, she had been on the short list of candidates for attorney general.
From 2010 to 2019, Emehelu was an Assistant U.S. Attorney; Sherrill and Emehelu worked together as federal prosecutors.
Emehelu served as chief of asset recovery and anti-money laundering, overseeing federal asset forfeiture, money laundering, and victim restitution programs. She prosecuted complex financial fraud cases. She also worked in the criminal and special prosecutions division, where she joined a team that prosecuted major financial crimes and public corruption cases.
She previously practiced at Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi, where she handled white-collar criminal defense and government investigations and co-chaired the firm’s banking and finance group. From 2004 to 2010, Emehelu was an associate at Debevoise & Plimpton, one of the country’s most prestigious law firms. She had also worked at Sullivan & Cromwell, another white shoe firm.
Emehelu was born in Nigeria and emigrated to the U.S. at age three; both of her parents were physicians. She initially lived in Chicago, where her father was a surgical resident, and her mother completed her family medicine training. Her family moved to Pittsburgh five years later.
A graduate of Yale University and Yale Law School, Emehelu clerked for U.S. District Judge James R. Spencer in the Eastern District of Virginia and later was an adjunct professor at Montclair State University. She is married to Ike Emehelu, a fellow Yale Law School graduate who heads the projects and energy transition practice at Akin, a major international law firm.
Her paternal grandfather, Dr. Fabian Anene Ositadimma Udekwu, met her Swedish grandmother at a party for international students while he was attending Loyal University Medical School in Chicago; he would later become one of the pioneers of open-heart surgery in Africa. They raised ten children – Emehelu’s father was the eldest – primarily in Nigeria; during the Nigerian Civil War between 1967 and 1970, her father lived in Sweden with grandparents, Sven and Hildegard Bystrom. Her maternal grandfather was also Nigerian.
Sherrill is now expected to nominate a new state comptroller.

