Asylum has always been hard to win in the United States. The rules are strict, narrow, and don’t always account for the dangers people face today. Increasingly, however, people who fear returning to their home country are being removed without a hearing. Through our observations in immigration courts across the country, we have documented a pattern of procedural removal – people ordered removed without a judge ever hearing why they sought protection in the first place.
Take a Nicaraguan man who appeared for a preliminary hearing – similar to an arraignment – in a Miami immigration court. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) attorney moved to dismiss his case, the judge granted the motion, and then the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents waiting in the hallway arrested him. We don’t know why he was seeking asylum, but we do know that in recent years Nicaragua has targeted political dissidents, including democracy activists and Catholics, with growing brutality and impunity. Instead of scheduling a hearing to examine the merits of his claim, this government sent him to detention – and possibly to a country where he’s never been. That doesn’t tell us whether his claim would have succeeded. It tells us that his claim was never heard.
His case is not an anomaly. Over the last year, we have observed more than 3,500 asylum hearings in 107 courtrooms across 13 states and Puerto Rico, including in Newark. We have documented multiple ways in which the administration is hollowing out immigration courts – through paperwork, changing guidelines, and “pretermission” – to deny cases before evidence is presented.
Pretermission, or early denial, is particularly alarming. This directs an immigration judge to decide from preliminary filings that a person is ineligible for relief. There is no testimony. No evidence. No opportunity to respond. The government has not adjudicated the claim; it has found a way around it.
Third-country agreements are one particularly stark example of pretermission. In a Santa Ana courtroom, a Guatemalan asylum seeker was asked whether she would be safe in Ecuador or Uganda. “I’ve never been there,” she said. “I don’t know anyone there. Who will help me?” The judge responded, “Well, if you’ve never been there, how do you know you won’t be safe? Ecuador is confronting escalating organized-crime, a sharp increase in homicides, and a deeply alarming rise in femicide, while its strained asylum system cannot guarantee protection for someone sent there without legal status, income, or ties.
The woman was trapped. She could neither prove that she would be persecuted in a place she had never known nor avoid being sent there without proving it. Before the court considered why she fled Guatemala, she was ordered deported to Ecuador.
Some might say that immigrants don’t, or shouldn’t, have due process rights in the United States. U.S. law guarantees due process rights to all people and, specifically, to immigrants challenging their deportation on narrow but important grounds.
The erosion of those protections should concern everyone. What happens in immigration court strikes at the foundation of our justice system. A court is legitimate only when people have a meaningful opportunity to be heard by a decisionmaker who is able and willing to exercise independent judgment.
We have watched judges – including former DHS prosecutors appointed during Trump’s first administration–sigh and grumble as they are reduced to administering predetermined removal decisions rather than weighing protection claims. In informal conversations, judges lament people appearing before them without an understanding of what will happen or any practical chance to present their cases.
Another development should sound the alarm. Immigration courts are generally open to the public, enabling researchers like ourselves to watch and document as proceedings unfold. Recently, however, hearings are taking place outside official courts and in unmarked office buildings far from public view–places neither attorneys nor observers are permitted to enter. These clandestine courts appear to be the next step in a line of strategies that make the legal process harder to access, understand, and observe. We should be concerned about what we see in immigration court, and even more concerned about what we are not allowed to see.
Congress ceded immigration adjudication authority to the Department of Justice, and Congress can take it back. It should establish an independent court, create a public defender program for people facing removal, and provide those people whose cases were ended without a full and fair hearing the opportunity to have their claims heard.
The Supreme Court may ultimately decide whether these practices are lawful. Congress does not need to wait for that decision to confront what is already happening in immigration court. Congress can and must guarantee that everyone gets their day in court.
Amelia Frank-Vitale and Lauren Heidbrink are authors of “Dismantling Due Process: The Rise of Procedural Removal in U.S. Immigration Courts.”

