If a fourth grader isn’t keeping up in math class, most parents shrug and assume it will work itself out. But years later, when those parents unexpectedly have to pay $1,500 extra for their college freshman’s remedial math classes, suddenly they don’t feel so casual about it.
Last month the advocacy nonprofit Collaborative for Student Success released a study showing the math shortfalls of incoming freshmen at Rutgers-New Brunswick. There were multiple shocking findings about New Jersey’s flagship state school, but two in particular stood out: First, many students arrive with barely 7th-grade or even 5th-grade math skills, and have to take extra classes that cost their parents and eventually all of us taxpayers, too. Second, these underqualified students gained admission because, despite their obvious skill gaps, they earned A’s in math in middle and high school.
This is not a new problem. From 2016-2019, long before the COVID lockdown, less than 45% of New Jersey students tested proficient in math. Of the 560 districts, at least 60 of them had fewer than a quarter of students on grade level. And yet we know even those schools gave As, Bs and diplomas to plenty of students. When I tutored at Edna Mahan women’s prison in Clinton, NJ, my students had high school diplomas or GEDs, but in almost every case I first had to reteach them math from seventh, sixth, even fifth grade.
Nor is this a New Jersey-specific problem. These past few months UC San Diego has been roiled by findings that the percentage of freshmen needing basic math classes had grown 30-fold from 2020 to 2025. The UCal leadership, overriding their faculty’s recommendations, had dropped the admissions requirement to submit an SAT or ACT score. This forced admissions to rely on report card grades instead of the more objective standardized tests.
The result has unveiled the deep honesty gap between students’ actual proficiency and K-12 accountability. People say scores aren’t everything, but the problem is that grades are everything: achievement, effort, good classroom citizenship. All these elements matter, but we can’t let them block the line of sight to students’ actual proficiency.
Starts long before college
Moreover, this problem does not suddenly materialize at age 17 when students start applying to college. Today, 54% of New Jersey’s fourth graders are behind grade level in math, and overall New Jersey students are performing worse today in math than a decade ago. And once a child is behind, the child has only a 3% chance of ever reaching grade-level skills. That should be a frightening prospect for any parent of a struggling student. Low math scores don’t just “work themselves out.” Instead, more and more students fall behind each year.
We must decide as a society whether we’re serious about giving all students a quality education. How have we become so comfortable with half of our students (and upwards of 90% in some urban schools) sitting through years of school not comprehending the equations on the board? In contrast, what business would survive with these failure rates? Consumers are enraged when a product bought on Amazon arrives broken or missing parts. And yet we brush off the fact that one-half or more of students do not meet the academic standards in place for their very benefit. Instead, we advance them from grade to grade with good report cards to reassure their parents. We need serious recalibration.
This is why I have spent the past 15 years building and investing in programs to improve math education. Two years ago, I co-founded Wake Up Call NJ to shine a spotlight on how NJ students are actually performing. We have been sounding the alarm about the woeful math skill shortfalls in our state, the report card grades that paper over it, and the system’s quiet complacency about it.
Some possible remedies
Fortunately, if and when our leaders choose to tackle this crisis, there is a lot of low-hanging fruit within reach.
The first is awareness. As painful as it might be, parents need to know if their children really are at grade level. While state standardized tests are not perfect and never will be, they provide an essential yardstick for the skills our students are mastering – especially for math. Like the SAT and almost every other digital test, state test results need to be returned to teachers, parents and students within a couple of weeks of taking the test. That way, in early June teachers and parents can identify a child’s math gaps, the work they need to do to catch up over the summer, and the appropriate course placement for the following school year
Second, parents and teachers need to look at that score alongside the final report card grades. We need to build consistency and objectivity into those grades for the sake of colleges and employers.
Third, we need to commit to using summertime to help students catch up on their math gaps. Otherwise, they show up in September unable to build new knowledge without those missing skills; again, math is cumulative. A kid is a kid only once, and no child should have to feel like a deer in headlights at the start of a school year. We, the adults, owe kids a better experience than that.
At a higher level, we still depend on numerate people building our bridges, calibrating our syringes, and stress-testing the sensors in our cars. When Newark Liberty Airport’s air traffic control goes sideways, Jerseyans suddenly don’t feel so cavalier about math. We need to feel that urgency every day – on behalf of our kids and for our shared future. With the recent state test data, NAEP scores, PISA scores, Harvard and Stanford’s Education Scorecard, and now the Rutgers study, we don’t need another wake-up call. We need action and leadership.

