Commissioner of Education Lily Laux deserves tremendous credit for the spirit of openness and engagement she is bringing to the New Jersey Department of Education. Under her leadership, the department is inviting stakeholders into important conversations about school funding, expanding educational opportunities, and improving student achievement. Now is the time to bring a long-neglected issue to the table: the harm racial and economic segregation inflicts on children and the significant benefits that more integrated schools can offer all students.
Let’s start with a clear understanding of the damage that New Jersey’s intensely segregated school system causes. Segregated schools deprive all children, regardless of their background, the chance to learn and grow together. But the impact is most severe for Black and Latino students. Because of redlining, systemic racism, and housing discrimination, many Black and Latino students are not only often segregated by race and ethnicity but are also concentrated in high-poverty schools. A comprehensive report by the Joseph F. Cornwall Center at Rutgers illuminates the depth of the crisis.

Concentrating poor students in schools is problematic for a number of reasons. High-poverty schools must devote significant portions of their budgets to basic services and supports, leaving less for advanced coursework, enrichment, and other learning opportunities. High-poverty schools often struggle with high staff turnover and problematic attendance rates. The problem isn’t the teachers, students, or families; it’s the system that concentrates challenges and would overburden any school.
For decades, New Jersey has addressed the harm segregation causes with “separate but equal” strategies, most notably court mandates that require increased funding for poor districts. While these efforts have produced some gains, huge gaps in student achievement and educational opportunity endure. Moreover, many high-poverty districts serving Black and Latino children continue to be funded at a level below what is needed, according to the Education Law Center.
At the same time, charter schools have done little to address the underlying inequities in the system. In practice, students attending segregated public schools have merely been given the option of attending another segregated school. The Education Law Center estimates that roughly 85 percent of New Jersey’s 55,000 charter school students are Black or Latino and attend schools restricted to urban areas. In Red Bank, the charter school’s presence has further concentrated low-income students in the traditional K-8 public schools while diverting resources from the system. For the majority of children in Red Bank who attend the regular public schools, it’s a double blow.
Collectively, these efforts reflect a failure to confront a fundamental truth: a segregated education system will always be an unequal one. We continue to cling to the notion that we can make a separate and unequal system work with a few tweaks to the school funding formula or by adding charter schools, even though the charters are often even more segregated than the regular public schools themselves.
Meanwhile, an extensive body of evidence documenting the benefits of integrated schools is ignored. Decades of research have shown that racially and economically inclusive schools are among the most effective ways to improve student achievement, expand opportunity, and promote academic excellence. This is particularly the case when integration is combined with access to quality preschool programs and adequate school funding. Other studies have documented the lifelong economic benefits of attending an integrated school, including greater social mobility and an enhanced ability to succeed in a diverse society.
By rejecting integration as part of the solution and continuing to bet everything on “separate but equal,” we resemble the football coach who keeps running the same failed play, leaves the best players on the sidelines, and then grumbles about the result. Yet it’s not a game that is at stake. It’s the well-being of children and the success of our society.
Our experience at Red Bank Regional High School reinforces the finding that when done right, integration works. Meeting the needs of a diverse student population has inspired reforms and practices that help all students. Graduation rates for students of color and low-income students are higher than the state average, as is participation in advanced coursework. High-achievers and strivers from all backgrounds benefit through access to a wide range of challenging academic programs and options. Strong community engagement keeps the district accountable and helps ensure program support.
Moving forward, we need to do everything we can to ensure the best outcomes for all children in New Jersey by refuting the premise that segregation in schools is an immutable fact of life. Working together, New Jerseyans can take action that will start us on the path to reform. Leaders, educators, and parents should immediately advocate for integrated schools in communities where consolidation is relatively easy. In my district, for example, students from Little Silver, Red Bank, and Shrewsbury have attended an inclusive regional high school district since 1969. With the right incentives and support, this could be extended to the K–8 districts, including the Red Bank Charter School.
At the same time, we should identify and restructure programs that currently only provide more advantage to those communities that already have an advantage. County magnet schools, for example, need to be reformed to ensure they are racially and economically inclusive.
The state government should also provide generous funding incentives to encourage inter-district cooperation, promote inclusion in schools, and support districts that are already integrated. Suburban students should attend urban schools, just as urban students attend suburban ones. Great schools exist on both sides of the barrier that segregation has created, and inclusion will make them stronger.
Finally, since segregation and “redlining” can happen within schools as well as between districts, educators need to be equipped to identify the sources of inequity within schools and expand the use of practices that bring high-quality educational experiences to all students.
For many New Jerseyans, ending school segregation can feel at odds with their immediate interests–even if they support it in principle. Suburban taxpayers fear losing control over school resources or resent being asked to share advantages they believe they have earned and are entitled to keep. Meanwhile, residents and educators in districts that predominantly serve Black and Latino students have legitimate reasons to be wary of school integration in a state with a long history of separate and unequal schooling. This is especially the case when at least some of these districts are finally receiving additional funding and resources.
Against an entrenched status quo, the fight for inclusive schools needs champions willing to put the needs of students in New Jersey first. We can no longer ignore the harm that segregation does or deny the benefits that inclusion can bring. Now is the time to halt the retreat and extend the benefits of integrated schools to more communities, schools, and children.

