The basics:
- Gov. Mikie Sherrill appoints Shirley Emehelu lieutenant governor
- Emehelu to serve remainder of Dale Caldwell’s term through January 2030
- Caldwell resigned following an investigation substantiating workplace and ethics violations
- Assemblywoman Verlina Reynolds-Jackson withdrew from consideration
Gov. Mikie Sherrill selected acting Secretary of State Shirley Emehelu as New Jersey’s next lieutenant governor, filling the vacancy left by Dale Caldwell following his September resignation. Caldwell exited after an independent investigation substantiated three workplace conduct and state ethics violations.
The new appointment arrives Nov. 9, the final day of the 45-day deadline Sherrill had under the New Jersey Constitution to name Caldwell’s replacement.
Emehelu, a former federal prosecutor who previously served as acting state comptroller, was appointed acting secretary of state Sept. 25 following Caldwell’s resignation. Her selection comes after she helped oversee New Jersey’s Nov. 3 general election while acting as secretary of state.
Emehelu will serve the remainder of Caldwell’s term, which runs through January 2030. She becomes New Jersey’s fifth lieutenant governor.
Who is Shirley Emehelu?
Emehelu, 48, of Montclair, joined the Sherrill administration in January as acting state comptroller before being named acting secretary of state in September.
Prior to the administration, Emehelu served as executive assistant attorney general under former Gov. Phil Murphy, making her the third-highest-ranking official in the New Jersey Attorney General’s Office. She also spent nine years as an assistant U.S. attorney in New Jersey, where she prosecuted financial fraud cases and served as chief of asset recovery and anti-money laundering.
Emehelu previously worked at Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi (CSG Law), focusing on white-collar criminal defense and government investigations. She earned her bachelor’s degree and law degree from Yale University.
Emehelu was not the only candidate under consideration for the position.
Assemblywoman Verlina Reynolds-Jackson was also under consideration, before withdrawing her name from consideration.

In a Friday statement, Sherrill acknowledged Reynolds-Jackson’s decision and said she respected her choice to remain in her current position.
“I appreciate Assemblywoman Reynolds-Jackson’s willingness to step forward for consideration as Lieutenant Governor. I understand and respect her decision that now is not the right time for her,” Sherrill said. “She is a tireless champion for her district, and I’m pleased that she will continue to be a close partner.”
Reynolds-Jackson chairs the New Jersey Legislative Black Caucus. She has focused on education, healthcare, voting rights and expanding opportunities for working families.
Sherrill said she looks forward to continuing to work with Reynolds-Jackson on issues affecting Black communities and working families across New Jersey.
Caldwell’s resignation
As NJBIZ previously reported, Caldwell resigned Sept. 25, one day after Sherrill called for it, following an independent investigation conducted by Lowenstein Sandler LLP.
The 61-page report, dated Sept. 23, substantiated three violations involving workplace conduct and state ethics policies.
The first involved Caldwell making an inappropriate remark toward a female staffer after expressing romantic interest in her friend. According to the investigation, Caldwell told the staffer, “you young women are looking for young sperm,” after his advances were rejected.
Caldwell denied making the remark, but investigators found the staffer’s account credible.


The second violation involved Caldwell bringing personal guests to ticketed events without payment or reimbursement between Feb. 19 and May 23.
Investigators also found that Caldwell used his official position to advocate for the career advancement of a state employee with whom he was romantically involved.
Following the findings, Sherrill called for Caldwell’s resignation Sept. 24, giving him until the following day to step down. Caldwell resigned Sept. 25, leaving both the lieutenant governor and secretary of state positions vacant.
Sherrill subsequently appointed Emehelu acting secretary of state, putting her in charge of overseeing New Jersey’s elections just weeks before voters headed to the polls.
Watch Gov. Sherrill’s announcement here:
A 45-day deadline
Under the New Jersey Constitution, the governor has 45 days to appoint a new lieutenant governor following a vacancy. Caldwell’s Sept. 25 resignation started that timeline, giving Sherrill until Nov. 9 to name his replacement.
During the vacancy, Senate President Nicholas Scutari was next in line to serve as acting governor whenever Sherrill was outside New Jersey or otherwise unable to perform her duties.
With Emehelu taking over as lieutenant governor, those responsibilities return to the office.
The Constitution also allows Sherrill to appoint her lieutenant governor to lead a state department or agency or assign other responsibilities. Emehelu’s selection fills the vacancy more than six weeks after Caldwell’s resignation, bringing an end to the search for New Jersey’s next lieutenant governor.

