Fifteen years ago, New Jersey’s Anti-Bullying Bill of Rights Act was established for an essential purpose: To protect students and ensure that schools respond seriously and consistently to harassment, intimidation and bullying. It established detailed requirements for reporting, investigating, documenting and reviewing alleged incidents.
Yet from my experience in New Jersey as a former teacher and current school board leader, completing that process does not establish whether the affected student is actually now safe, whether the harmful behavior has stopped, or whether the school’s response succeeded.
The demands on schools are substantial. In its October 2023 testimony to the Anti-Bullying Task Force, the New Jersey School Boards Association’s representative described the law’s significant workload and funding burden. As a board member, I have seen the extensive interviewing and documentation that investigations require. We should ask whether the resources devoted to determining a statutory classification could accomplish more if directed toward understanding and resolving the underlying problem.
A disproportionate amount of attention is devoted to determining whether incidents meet the statutory criteria for HIB. But identifying an incident as HIB does not, by itself, protect a student or resolve the problem. A determination has been made and reported, but that does not establish whether students feel heard or safe. Although the act requires a response, requiring action is different from determining whether that action helped. The prominence of the HIB determination can also reinforce a misconception that conduct falling outside the statutory definition will receive a less serious response.
In Denville, families have contested HIB determinations, sometimes retaining attorneys in the hope that changing the designation would change the school’s response. Yet in cases we have discussed with our administration, changing the designation would not have changed the intervention. The response was based on the circumstances and seriousness of the conduct. Some non-HIB incidents warrant substantially greater intervention than incidents meeting the statutory definition.
Families deserve to understand this distinction. A finding that conduct is not HIB does not mean that nothing harmful occurred or that no action is warranted. Similarly, a substantiated finding does not establish that the harm has been addressed.
The emphasis on classification can also shape the investigation itself. When investigators must determine whether statutory elements are satisfied, those questions necessarily command attention. An investigation organized around resolution would place greater emphasis on relationships, power imbalances, patterns of behavior, vulnerabilities and opportunities to intervene. Those findings would more directly inform the response and potentially further a better outcome.
Training for schools could better reflect that purpose: Listening carefully, establishing facts fairly, recognizing abuse, selecting appropriate interventions and assessing whether they work. Responsibility matters, particularly when imposing discipline. But uncertainty about every detail of an incident should not prevent schools from providing protection and support. Effective assistance need not await complete agreement about blame.
I propose an overhaul that makes the response to harmful conduct — and its effectiveness — the organizing principle of accountability. When a student, parent, or staff member reports harm, the school should investigate what happened and determine what is needed to address it. A separate HIB designation need not govern that work.
Under this approach, accountability would follow the student’s experience beyond the initial decision. Has the behavior stopped? Does the student feel safe, heard and supported? Has retaliation occurred? What must change if the intervention has failed? Families would need a meaningful avenue to challenge inadequate responses, with fair procedures preserved for students facing consequences.
In the Denville K–8 school district, we have begun moving toward this emphasis while fulfilling existing HIB requirements. We have revised our code of conduct policy and regulations to reflect these priorities and begun explaining to families that the quality of our response does not depend on an HIB designation.
We have also begun training and implementing restorative practices to support accountability, address harm and develop healthier relationships. These practices must be appropriate to the circumstances. Alongside this work, we are developing a feedback process through which families can report whether they felt supported and whether the problem was resolved. A later follow-up will ask whether those improvements lasted, with an anonymous option for those uncomfortable offering critical feedback. Aggregated findings will help the Board evaluate the effectiveness of district responses.
This work is in its infancy. We cannot yet claim demonstrated improvements or savings. But we believe it is beginning to shift the focus back where it belongs: Whether students are safe, feel supported and receive help that addresses the problem.
Statewide reform should examine how time, training, and funding could be redirected from classification toward effective intervention and follow-up. We should judge a redesigned system by its ability to protect students, respond fairly, prevent recurrence and identify failures requiring further action. New Jersey has invested considerable effort in determining what to call harmful conduct. It is time to direct that effort toward helping schools stop the harm and ensuring that students and families feel safe, supported and heard.

